Change orders and contracts

How to terminate a subcontractor properly

Terminate a subcontractor by following the subcontract exactly: document the default, send a written cure notice with a clear deadline, involve the surety if the sub is bonded, then issue a written termination notice, secure the site and materials, and track completion costs separately.

Two construction professionals review paper plans beside a tablet at a jobsite workbench.
Plan reviews connect field conditions, drawings, and the next decisions on a job. AI-generated illustration.

To terminate a subcontractor properly, follow the termination clause in your subcontract step by step. For a termination for default, that usually means documenting the failure, sending a written cure notice with a specific deadline, notifying the sub's surety if there is a performance bond, and only then issuing a written termination notice. After termination, inventory the work and materials, secure the site, hire the replacement, and track every dollar of completion cost separately so you can recover it. Skipping a step can turn a justified termination into a wrongful one, and the damages then run the other way.

Termination is the most serious move a GC can make on a subcontract. It should be the last option after a supplement, a schedule recovery meeting, or a negotiated exit has failed. When it is the right call, the paper trail decides whether it holds up.

Default or convenience: pick the right path

Two ways to end a subcontract
FactorTermination for defaultTermination for convenience
BasisSub failed to perform: schedule, quality, manpower, payment of its own suppliers, safetyGC or owner chooses to end the work, no fault needed
Usual prerequisitesWritten notice and a chance to cure, per the subcontractWritten notice per the subcontract
Who pays extra completion costDefaulted sub (and surety, if bonded)GC or owner
What the sub getsOften nothing more until completion costs are knownTypically payment for work done and some close-out costs, per the clause
Risk if done wrongMay be converted to convenience, or a wrongful termination claimDisputes over the settlement amount

Federal contracts show how these fit together, and many subcontracts copy the logic. Under FAR 52.249-10, if a default termination later turns out to be unjustified or the delay was excusable, the parties' rights are the same as if the termination had been for convenience. Under the termination for convenience clause in FAR 52.249-2, the contractor is paid for work done with a reasonable allowance for profit on that work, and the final settlement proposal is due within 1 year of the effective date unless extended. Some subcontracts give the GC a convenience option; some do not. Read yours.

Step-by-step: terminating a subcontractor for default

1. Build the record before you need it

From the first sign of trouble, document it: crew counts versus what the schedule needs, missed milestones, failed inspections, safety violations, unpaid supplier notices, and every meeting where the problem was discussed. The daily log and weekly meeting minutes are your main evidence.

2. Send a written cure notice

State the specific failures, cite the subcontract sections, say what the sub must do to cure, and give a deadline that matches the subcontract (often expressed in days, such as 48 or 72 hours, or longer for bigger problems). Federal practice is a reasonable benchmark: FAR 49.402-3 has the contracting officer give written notice and 10 days, or longer if needed, to cure before terminating for certain failures. Send it by the method the notice clause requires.

3. Notify the surety

If the sub has a performance bond, read the bond's notice requirements and copy the surety on the cure notice. Many bonds require the obligee to give notice and meet with the surety before declaring default. Missing that step can weaken your claim on the bond.

4. Consider a supplement before termination

Many subcontracts let the GC supplement the sub's crew and back-charge the cost after notice. This keeps the job moving and is often less disruptive than full termination. Document supplemented hours and costs carefully.

5. Issue the written termination notice

If the cure period passes without a cure, send a termination notice that references the cure notice, states the uncured failures, gives the effective date, and directs the sub on demobilization, materials on site, and turning over documents.

6. Secure the site and inventory

On the effective date, walk the work with the sub if they will attend, photograph everything, inventory materials and equipment, and record percent complete by schedule of values line. Change access codes if needed.

7. Complete the work and track costs

Get competitive pricing for the completion work where time allows. Track all completion costs, extra supervision, and delay costs on separate codes. The recovery is usually the cost to complete minus the unpaid balance of the subcontract.

Worked example: a framing sub that stopped showing up

Here is an illustration. A GC has a $420,000 framing subcontract on a 24-unit townhome job. The sub has billed and been paid $250,000, with $25,000 in retainage held. Crew size drops from 12 to 3, and two weekly milestones are missed. The GC sends a cure notice citing the manpower and schedule clauses with a 72-hour cure period (per the subcontract), copying the surety. The sub does not respond. The GC terminates, inventories the work, and brings in a replacement.

Example termination accounting
ItemAmount
Original subcontract$420,000
Paid to date$250,000
Retainage held$25,000
Unpaid balance (including retainage)$170,000
Replacement framer to complete$188,000
Extra supervision and schedule recovery$14,000
Total cost to complete$202,000
Shortfall to recover from sub or surety$32,000

Because the GC can show the cure notice, the surety notice, the daily logs, and separately coded completion costs, the surety claim is straightforward. Without that file, the sub could argue it was never given a chance to cure.

Also keep paying attention to the sub's lower tiers. Before the replacement starts, collect the terminated sub's supplier list, check which suppliers sent preliminary notices, and confirm what was delivered and paid for. Material on site that the sub never paid for can come with a supplier claim attached.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Locking the sub out without notice. This is the classic wrongful termination fact pattern.
  • A cure period shorter than the subcontract allows. Count the days exactly as the contract defines them.
  • Forgetting the surety. Bond notice rules are strict.
  • Paying the sub after termination without tracking the balance. Hold the unpaid balance until completion costs are known.
  • Ignoring the sub's suppliers. Unpaid suppliers may have lien or bond rights. Check lien waivers and preliminary notices before releasing any money.
  • Letting anger set the timeline. Terminate when the paper is ready, not on the day of the argument.

Templates, terms, and tools

Related reading: how to manage subcontractors on the job site, what to include in a subcontract agreement, and how to prequalify subcontractors so you terminate fewer of them. Terms: back-charge, subcontractor default insurance, and surety. Smart Business Automator keeps each sub's daily log entries, notices, insurance, billing, and back-charges on one record, which is the file you need if a termination ever happens. See subcontractor compliance automation.

Frequently asked questions

Can I fire a subcontractor without notice?

Usually not for default. Most subcontracts require written notice and an opportunity to cure. Terminating without following those steps can expose you to a wrongful termination claim. Some contracts allow termination for convenience with notice instead.

How long should a cure period be?

Whatever the subcontract says. Many use a set number of days or hours. Federal practice under FAR 49.402-3 uses 10 days, or longer if necessary, for certain failures. Use the contract's period and count it exactly.

Does a terminated subcontractor get its retainage?

Not right away in a default termination. Retainage and any unpaid balance are typically held and applied to the cost of completing the work. Any remainder after completion is settled under the subcontract.

What should a termination notice include?

A reference to the cure notice, the uncured failures, the subcontract sections relied on, the effective date, and instructions for demobilization, materials, and documents. Copy the surety if there is a bond.

Sources

  1. Acquisition.gov: FAR 49.402-3 Procedure for default
  2. Acquisition.gov: FAR 52.249-10 Default (Fixed-Price Construction)
  3. Acquisition.gov: FAR 52.249-2 Termination for Convenience of the Government (Fixed-Price)
Written and edited by

Maurice Francois writes and edits construction operations guides for Smart Business Automator. More from Maurice on the Scaling Legends podcast.

Get a free assessment